Investment Gains

August 7, 2010

Uncertainty of Tax Cut Rules Affecting Tax Planners

Don’t look to your tax planner for help in preparing a 2010 tax strategy, at least not until Congress quits the political games and resolves the issue on tax cuts.

At the end of 2010, tax cuts enacted during the Bush years (2001 and 2003) are scheduled to expire, which will increase federal income tax rates for some Americans. Also at stake are taxes on dividends and capital gains, as well as tax credits and deductions.

Most Democrats and Republicans agree the middle class should not have to face tax hikes. But what about high-earners, families with income above $250,000 and singles above $200,000? Therein lies the battle.

The Obama administration favors allowing the Bush tax cuts to expire for wealthier Americans. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner this week argued the Administration plan would raise billions for the government with minimal impact on the economy.

“The top 2% are the least likely to spend those tax cuts, certainly not in comparison to the 98% of Americans who make less than $250,000 per-year,” said Geithner.

Republicans, though, are firmly opposed to the Administration plan. “We don’t believe anybody should face a tax hike, particularly in a recession,” said Don Stewart, press secretary for Republican Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell.

“It’s clear they want to hold hostage tax cuts for the middle class for their desire for more tax cuts for the wealthy,” countered Jim Manley, spokesman for Democratic Senate Leader Harry Reid.

As the tax rate deadline ticks, professional tax planners are growing impatient.

“They’re dysfunctional,” complained Evan Snapper, financial advisor with Anchin Block & Anchin. “It’s terrible. It’s a political game that’s hurting the country.”

Usually accountants advise clients to defer income and investment gains until the following year — why owe taxes now when you can put them off?

But the possibility of higher tax rates in 2011 calls that logic into question.

“It’s tax planning turned on its head,” said Doug Flynn, a certified financial planner at Flynn Zito Capital Management.

Because of the uncertainty, planners can’t yet advise clients whether to sell real estate, stocks and bonds or to convert traditional Individual Retirement Accounts into Roth IRAs, which requires payment of taxes on investment gains.

“It’s putting us almost in a standstill. We’re trying to get our ammunition ready, but we’re not certain what ammunition to load,” said Steven Bandini, a certified public accountant at Zapken & Loeb.

And for entrepreneurs who have to worry about both business and personal income taxes, it’s added an extra layer of uncertainty on top of the sluggish economy.

New York business owner Ellen Donath says she’s won’t even consider hiring additional staff, until the issue is resolved because she’s unsure of whether more of her company’s revenue will have to go for taxes.

“You don’t have a clue of what you can do,” said Donath, who runs Donath Communications, an advertising, marketing and design firm. “When you know what the rules of the game are, then you can play the game.”

source: money.cnn.com

Filed under Taxes by

Permalink Print Comment