I have been looking at the tax plans for both presidential candidates. I believe that both have good ideas and bad ideas. But it’s fair to say that we really don’t know if either of them will work.

It is true that Barack Obama’s plan is focused more on helping the “common man”, by providing tax relief to middle America - but at what expense?

Will a measly $1,000 a year really make the difference? How are we going to pay for it? The national deficit is growing at an alarming rate and additional tax cuts will just add to it.  This could have long term devastating effects on the economy and the value of the once “almighty dollar”.

On the other hand, John McCain’s tax plan calls for giving big business and the highest earners the larger tax cuts.  The “trickle down economics” of the republican plan doesn’t sit well with most Americans. But let’s be fair - it had worked in the past (some will obviously disagree).

So what is the right course to take on tax reform?  Everyone has ideas, but no one knows for sure.  I believe that giving the middle and lower classes a tax break can help the “psychology” of America.  It can help average folks feel like there is a future - that this economic crisis can be turned around.

The Obama plan calls for promoting and supporting domestic small businesses and that is great for America.  I believe that John McCain feels that same way, but he hasn’t really come across as the savior for the middle class.

I think both candidates agree that Alternative Minimum Tax must be eliminated. The tax reforms of 2001 expire in 2010 and AMT will tax more than 20 million Americans, if it is not changed.

John McCain’s plan calls for cutting the corporate tax rate to 25%, down 10% from the current 35%.  But will that only help big business?

Both candidates agree in health care reform. But again, it will cost trillions, yes trillions of dollars in the long run. Can we afford it - can we afford not to do it?

The bottom line is this: We won’t know what will work until a new president is elected,and the tax plan has time to mature.

I hate to say it - but most Americans want immediate gratification and middle class Americans deserve something to look forward to. The John McCain plan sounds great for big business and the wealthy - but what about the rest of us?